From Pittsburghs Steel Curtain in the 1970s to Chicagos Monsters of the Midway in the 80s to Seattles Legion of Boom more recently, dominant defenses have often been the story of the NFL postseason.
High-powered offenses might generate the highlights, the fantasy points and victories in the regular season. But more often than not the top defenses have managed to hold those dynamic offenses in check when the weather turns colder and the games get more important in the postseason.
Yet, after one of the most prolific offensive regular seasons in NFL history, the question is can defenses still lead the way to a championship?
“I have no idea,” said San Francisco cornerback Richard Sherman, a key member of Seattles 2013 championship defense. “I dont think the league really wants that or cares to have that thing again. They care more about offensive football, so thats what theyll get. To have a special defensive group to play that well for so long would be very difficult to do because of the style of defense and the rules. … I think its going to be harder and harder to make the Hall of Fame from defense.”
Playing defense in the NFL perhaps has never been harder, with the intimidating hits on receivers and quarterbacks now outlawed, even the most minor downfield contact resulting in penalties, and quarterbacks more accurate and efficient than ever while running the new spread offenses.
This year featured the highest passer rating (92.9), most yards per play (5.6) and second-most points per game (46.7) in NFL history. It seems like playing great defense is almost impossible.
“You cant use it as an excuse because they still let us hit, OK?” said Dallas defensive coordinator Rod Marinelli, an assistant on the 2002 Tampa Bay team that won a Super Bowl behind its defense.
“Ive always believed in the speed of the defense. And thats the hitting. Theyve got holes. Weve got to hit the holes. Weve got to hit them. And weve got to make it a physical game. Weve got be smart, helmet to helmet, got to be smart on the quarterback, some of those things. And you try to teach it, keep our speed and playing fast. Some of the things down the field, push-offs and all that stuff, its tough.”
Thats been part of a season that had first-year starter Patrick Mahomes throwing for 50 TD passes and more than 5,000 yards for Kansas City, Drew Brees set more records at age 39 in New Orleans, Tom Brady maintain his winning ways in his 40s for New England, and Sean McVays offense tormenting opposing teams all year long for the Rams.
But those teams that feature four of the five most efficient offenses in the league, according to Football Outsiders, and defenses that have been far less consistent will get the opening weekend of the postseason off.
That will provide a bit of a throwback look on wild-card weekend with many of the leagues top defenses taking center stage in hopes that they can get on a run like the one the Denver Broncos had three years ago to win a Super Bowl.
“I think its still definitely possible,” said Broncos linebacker Todd Davis, a member of that title-winning team. “I dont feel like it has to be 51-54. It really doesnt. I feel like you can really stop teams if you play close defense, you play tight on receivers, play great in man coverage and you can really stop people.”
Many of the teams playing this weekend have shown that ability this season, led by the NFLs top-ranked scoring defense in Chicago. An already-strong unit only got better with the acquisition of elite pass rusher Khalil Mack before the season.
With Mack and Akiem Hicks wreaking havoc up front and Eddie Jackson and Kyle Fuller providing big plays from the secondary, the Bears appear to have the defense best equipped for a long postseason run, starting with Sundays home game against defending champion Philadelphia.
“Dominant, thats it,” Hicks said. “We are aggressive. We like to hit. All the stuff that I was (saying) before the season started, were everything that we said we were. And hopefully we can get to another level for these playoffs.”
The Bears arent alone. Six of those 10 most efficient defenses are playing this weekend: Baltimore, Houston, the Chargers, Dallas and Indianapolis.
Ball-control offense and dominant defense have been a tried-and-true formula for teams like Baltimore and Seattle, who have combined for three Super Bowl championships and five appearances in the title game this century with that recipe.
“You either believe in something or you dont,” Carroll said. “I think just staying the course and knowing were on to something. Believing in the history. We know what were capable of doing. Weve shown it over a lot of years. Youre always adapting, but its staying what youre true to. I think thats what is happening. We look like a team that we have seen before, and thats powerful.”