Opinion: Six reasons why Meghan Markle divides people — even Americans

Home World Update Opinion: Six reasons why Meghan Markle divides people — even Americans
Opinion: Six reasons why Meghan Markle divides people — even Americans

Related Story: Meghan Markle has it so much easier than Princess Mary did Related Story: Meghan Markle's father reportedly in hospital again as will-he won't-he saga drags on

If you thought every American would be celebrating the prospect of a Yankee taking up residence in the Royal household, you'd be mistaken.

As Prince Harry and Meghan prepare to wed, there has been an astounding level of venom aimed at both of them, on both sides of the Atlantic.

Far from being the happy, feathery event that certainly Kensington Palace and television networks hoped for, the wedding has unpacked layers of discontent among the Queen's subjects and her former subjects alike.

As Tom Wells of The Sun put it on Twitter: "This has to be the worst build-up to a Royal wedding since Henry VIII last went down on one knee."

Wallis Simpson, who married Prince (formerly King) Edward after he abdicated the British throne.

The anti-Meghan outcry has caused no level of surprise and consternation at news outlets and websites that follow the Royals, and even those that marginally mention the Royal couple.

While they value the traffic the pair have brought in, digital editors have discovered they can't leave their comments sections unchecked, or else the nastiness takes hold.

"The most surprising thing about covering Meghan's fashion isn't the fashion at all," says Susan Kelley, who created What Kate Wore, the popular site tracking the Duchess of Cambridge's style, and also oversees What Meghan Wore, which features attire and activities.

"It's been the level of animosity directed at her and the number of comments on the site and on Facebook that couldn't be published because of the tone or language."

Even a food writer friend who posted an innocuous "where to watch the nuptials" post this week was blindsided by attacks on Meghan.

She is already the most controversial British Royal bride since Camilla, the Duchess of Cornwall, who many people will never embrace because she succeeded Diana, Princess of Wales.

Meghan readily brings to mind the uproar over Wallis Simpson, the twice-divorced American for whom Edward VIII gave up the throne.

In retrospect, those women had it much, much easier than Meghan. In watching the Royal drama for the better part of 18 months, I've come up with a list of six objections to her marriage, led by the big one they never had to address.

1. She's biracial

The first, and unmistakable overtone in every conversation about her is racism. Meghan is biracial, and identifies herself as such. Her mother Doria is African-American. Her father Thomas is white.

This is far from unusual in public life. President Barack Obama was biracial, with a white mother and black father, although he identified as black.

Meghan Markle and her mother Doria Ragland are clapping while standing

Academy Award winning actress Halle Berry is biracial. Canadian rapper Drake is biracial. So is football star Colin Kaepernick.

Although intermarriage was outlawed in many parts of the US during the first two-thirds of the 20th century, Americans who grew up in the 1970s and after are likely to know mixed-race couples, and socialise and go to school with biracial kids.

For a lot of people, especially in major urban and college cities, Meghan's background would only bring on a shrug.

But, there is an old American saying that one drop of blood makes you black, and, in some of the most bigoted commenters' eyes, makes you unfit to be a princess of the United Kingdom.

Says Kelley: "I never expected to see the sort of negative, derogatory and outright racist comments we have encountered in writing about Meghan's style."

This is even true when What Kate Wore runs a photo of the Duchess and Meghan at the same event, Kelley says.

Kensington Palace tried to attack this head on when Harry and Meghan were first dating in 2016. In an unprecedented statement, the Palace said: "His girlfriend, Meghan Markle, has been subject to a wave of abuse and harassment. Some of this has been very public – the smear on the front page of a national newspaper; the racial undertones of comment pieces; and the outright sexism and racism of social media trolls and web article comments."

Said the Palace: "This is not a game — it is her life, and his."

Tight shot of Megan Markle smiling and looking past the camera.

That did little to stop the racist comments, and now Harry and Meghan face a future in which this is a day to day part of their lives.

If you think it will die down, just look at any internet post that is at all flattering to Camilla. The Diana fans are out in constant force.

2. She's divorced

But racism isn't the only thing that Meghan deals with.

The second most-frequently heard objection is that she is divorced, while Harry has never married.

The critics are conveniently forgetting that Princes Charles and Andrew are also divorced, as is Princess Anne. American first marriages still fail at a rate of 40 per cent to 50 per cent, although the British divorce rate has been dropping.

3. Unbelievably, her fashion

Commenters also have taken Meghan apart for her hairstyle, and fashionably loose-fitting clothing. It doesn't help that she's far more fashion forward than Kate, whose pristine public style often seems to have been voted on by a committee.

4. She 'dumped' her rescue dog

Fourth is an objection from animal lovers, who bemoan the fact that she left one of her aged rescue dogs behind when she moved to London from Toronto.

5. She's American

Prince Harry and Meghan Markle sit together, holding hands, with Ms Markle's engagement ring visible on her hand.

I'm putting her American nationality at fifth, although you might argue that it should rank higher. Lots of us thought that the Royal wedding might cement and repair the "special relationship" between the US and Britain — our best for their best.

But that theory seems as much in tatters as the current political climate. Apparently, Harry was supposed to pick a red, white and blue bride echoing the British flag, not ours.

I've seen Facebook comments from my own American friends asking, "Why isn't Harry marrying a British girl?"

There is plenty of sniping as well from British ex-pats who predict the marriage won't make it past five years, and accuse Meghan of being a gold digger.

6. She's a TV actress

That final critique applies to Meghan's choice of an acting career. To be honest, I've never watched Suits, save for a glimpse at an episode or two to see what she did on the show.

In an era when quality television programs have swept over the networks, cable television and streaming services, Suits remains a guilty pleasure for its viewers and a skipable one for the rest of us.

Meghan might be a talented actress, with university degrees in drama and international affairs, but she's never been showcased in the kind of TV that scoops up Emmy Awards and BAFTAs.

Margot Robbie in Tourism Australia ad taking off Croc Dundee

Would it make people feel better if Harry was instead marrying one of the better young actresses of our time, such as Emma Stone, Saoirse Ronan or Margot Robbie? Possibly.

It hasn't gone unremarked that Meghan seems all too willing to ditch her acting career for activism. She won't be like Princess Grace, who fended off many efforts to entice her back to film. For Meghan, been there, done that, now on to charity work.

But a slightly better professional resume might have quieted some of the haters. If you take all the complaints together, it adds up to one angry beehive. Says Kelley:

"The volume of comments that couldn't be published on the blogs or that had to be deleted on the respective Facebook pages is far beyond anything I anticipated."

All these reasons might not matter a whit historically. Thanks to the birth of Kate and Williams' children, Harry is way down in the line of succession, so there's only a miniscule chance of a King Harry and Queen Meghan.

Thus far, the pair have managed to smile their way through every crisis that takes place, including whether Meghan's father, sadly in poor health, will walk her down the aisle.

But on Saturday, Meghan will marry her prince at a time when the world is divided about almost everything, including her.

Unwittingly, that makes her the perfect Royal bride for our times.

Micheline Maynard is an American journalist and author who threw a breakfast party to watch Princess Diana's wedding, but slept through William and Kate's.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.